Question on 'All or Nothing'

[jvil.livejournal.com]

I have been wondering about this since 5x10 album came out, why wasn't 'All or Nothing' not on it?  It wasn't a single  but there was a PV, similar to 'Lucky Man' that was not a single but it was included in the album.  So I was kind of disappointed that 'All or Nothing' was not , I actually like this song very much though it was one of their earlier work.

I seen an informal list for the upcoming 5x10 Clips DVD and I was hoping that it would since I think ALL of the MV were supposed to be there.  But I don't think it's on it either, again, I'm a bit disppointed.  So, does anyone have any idea to this is the case?  Thank you in advance.

Comments

[silverxrainx.livejournal.com]

Actually Lucky Man was not included on the 5x10 album. It only included all the official A sides of all the singles and 10 songs of the members choices.
I think this also applies to the 5x10 Clips DVD

I was a bit disappointed too... XD

[jvil.livejournal.com]

Lucky Man wasn't on the regular version? I should check my album again. Thanks for the reply.

[crazytammu.livejournal.com]

Ooops, I edited my comment because I realized I wasn't really answering your question. There's an official list of the PVs that will be included on the DVD on Johnny's: http://www.johnnys-net.jp/j/artists/arashi/disco/_popup/pop_allthebest_dvd.html

I don't think I see "All or Nothing" on it. I'm not sure why...maybe somebody else will be able to answer that.

[jvil.livejournal.com]

Thank you for the list. Too bad, it's not on. I thought All or Nothing's PV was very done too.

[zomboid.livejournal.com]

I think the All or Nothing PV that you see is the end of the All or Nothing DVD where it culminated in the members showing off their skills that they learned through out the DVD? I think that might be why it's not included because it was never really released as a stand alone single.

Hope this was helpful.

[icedragontmr.livejournal.com]

All or Nothing wasn't actually a pv. It was just a part of the DVD actually. They did re-release the song on an album, I think, but it's really only a small clip that is in the DVD of the All or Nothing DVD.

[jvil.livejournal.com]

Thank you both! This makes a lot of sense now, how the All or Nothing DVD is connected to the PV.

[rininjapan.livejournal.com]

See I never even knew that Lucky Man wasn't an official single until I realized it was Member Selected for the LE 5x10 disc. I was soooo shocked it wasn't a single, that it made me believe in them choosing it even more, even though I'm not a big fan of the song.

As for All or Nothing, I don't even really think I've heard the song properly....It just didn't stand out as much as Lucky Man I don't think.

Sorry I got off track. Just still in Lucky Man shock. ^^;

[jennie118.livejournal.com]

Lucky Man was on the LE disc?? I dont remember seeing it on there. I thought Lucky Man wasnt included in the best album. Need to go and check now.....

[itshelene.livejournal.com]

Lucky Man is not on the LE disc. I never missed it because I am not a fan of the song. It's one of those songs that are much better live than anything - best part of it is Nino's "Irrashaimase!" x3 + Ohno-kun's "Mirai wa" (the bridge)- love it:) and they are not on the studio version.